BLOCKBUSTER TRADE IDEA: Former Canadiens Scout Proposes Sensational Jason Robertson Deal Between Habs and Stars

MONTREAL – A stunning trade proposal from a former Montreal Canadiens scout has set the hockey world ablaze, suggesting a blockbuster deal that would see Dallas Stars’ superstar Jason Robertson land in Montreal in exchange for a package built around Cole Caufield.

The proposal, which has been circulating among NHL insiders, would send Robertson and a 2025 second-round pick to Montreal, while the Canadiens would part ways with Cole Caufield, defenseman Kaiden Guhle, and a 2026 first-round pick. The former scout—who remains unnamed—insists the trade would be a “win-win” for both franchises, offering Montreal a proven goal-scorer to build around and giving Dallas a younger sniper, a defensive cornerstone, and a future high pick.

WHY IT MAKES SENSE FOR MONTREAL

For the Canadiens, acquiring Robertson would instantly provide them with a dominant, top-line winger who has already proven he can score at an elite level. The 24-year-old put up 109 points in 2022-23 and has continued to be a force for the Stars. Pairing him with Nick Suzuki would give Montreal a true franchise duo, accelerating their rebuild.

However, the cost is steep. Moving Caufield—a fan favorite and a lethal scorer in his own right—along with Guhle, one of the team’s most promising young defensemen, would be a tough pill to swallow. The loss of a 2026 first-round pick also raises concerns about long-term flexibility.

DOES THIS HELP DALLAS?

At first glance, trading a superstar like Robertson seems unthinkable for the Stars. However, some argue this package could be too good to ignore. Caufield, while slightly smaller than Robertson, is a natural goal-scorer and could thrive alongside Dallas’ established stars. Guhle would bolster a defense corps that could use an infusion of young talent, while the future first-round pick would help Dallas stay competitive long-term.

One NHL executive, speaking anonymously, noted:

“The Stars would be giving up a proven superstar, but in return, they get a guy who could score 40+ goals, a solid young defenseman, and a first-rounder. If they feel Caufield can match Robertson’s production in a new system, it might not be as crazy as it sounds.”

FAN REACTIONS: GENIUS OR INSANE?

Predictably, reactions from fans have been divided. Canadiens supporters are dreaming of a Suzuki-Robertson connection, while others are unwilling to sacrifice both Caufield and Guhle. Stars fans, on the other hand, are questioning whether Caufield can truly replace Robertson’s impact.

One Habs fan on social media posted:

“I love Cole, but Jason Robertson is a legit superstar. If this is real, Montreal has to do it.”Meanwhile, a Stars fan fired back: “Dallas would be crazy to trade Robertson. He’s the kind of player you keep forever.”

WILL THIS TRADE HAPPEN?

While there’s no indication that either team is actually discussing such a deal, the former scout’s proposal has certainly ignited debate. With the NHL trade deadline approaching, anything is possible—but for now, this remains one of the most talked-about “what if” scenarios of the season.

Would you pull the trigger on this trade? Or is it too risky for either side? Let the debate begin!